Key takeaways
- Keep it if leased Keller comparables cover every cost once the homestead exemption is gone, the rate is low and the hold is long.
- Tax Code 11.13(b) exempts $140,000 of a homestead's value from school tax; a rental loses it unless the narrow 11.13(l) absence rule fits.
- IRS Publication 523: the exclusion needs 24 months of ownership and residence in the 5 years before the sale, so renting starts a clock.
- In the illustrative example, year one runs minus $2,100 and year two plus $1,950, while a sale would leave $190,000 in cash.
- Our rent or sell page asks three questions: does the rent cover the mortgage, taxes and insurance, do you need the equity, what is your rate?
Keep your Keller house as a rental if the rent from leased Keller comparables covers every cost after the homestead exemption ends, your mortgage rate is low and you expect to hold for years. Sell if you need the equity, the honest numbers stay negative into year two, or the IRS home sale window is about to close on a large gain. Owners in Fort Worth and North Richland Hills run the same checks; Keller changes the inputs.
Below: the seven rules that change when you move out, the tax line, the rent line, the mortgage and the IRS window, an illustrative two-year example, how the answers usually point, and how we help with both sides.
What changes when you move out of a Keller house and rent it
Here are the seven rules that change when your Keller home becomes a rental, what each one says as we read it in November 2026, and what it means for the keep-or-sell decision:
| What changes | The rule as read | What it means for keep or sell |
|---|---|---|
| School district homestead exemption | Tax Code 11.13(b): $140,000 of the appraised value of a residence homestead is exempt from school district tax. | Once the exemption ends, school tax is figured on that value too. The keep side carries a higher tax line than your current bill. |
| What counts as a homestead | 11.13(j)(1)(D): the structure must be occupied as the owner's principal residence. | A house leased to a tenant while you live elsewhere stops meeting that test. |
| A temporary absence | 11.13(l)(1): less than two years, you intend to return, and no different principal residence. | Fits a short assignment with a plan to move back, not a permanent move. Ask the appraisal district about your facts. |
| The 10% appraisal limit | Tax Code 23.23(c): the limit expires on January 1 of the first tax year neither you nor your spouse qualifies for an 11.13 exemption. | The taxable value can move toward market value from that year on. |
| The home sale exclusion | IRS Pub 523: up to $250,000 ($500,000 married filing jointly) if you owned and lived in the home at least 24 months of the 5 years before the sale. | Renting starts a clock: the longer you rent, the closer you get to losing the exclusion. |
| Depreciation while rented | Pub 523: gain equal to depreciation allowed or allowable after May 6, 1997 cannot be excluded. | Even a sale inside the window carries a taxable piece from the rental years. |
| State tax on the gain | Texas Constitution art. VIII, sec. 24-b: no state tax on an individual's capital gains. | Only the federal side matters for the gain; ask your CPA. |
How to read this table: the first four rows raise the cost of keeping, the next two set a deadline on selling, and the last one removes a worry. None of them decides the question alone; together they tell you which numbers to put in the example below. This is general information, not tax advice.
The general version of this decision, with a fill-in worksheet, is should I sell or rent my house in DFW. This guide is the Keller-specific read.
The tax line: what moving out does to a Keller tax bill
The tax bill you pay while you live in the house is not the bill a rental will carry. A residence homestead, in Tax Code 11.13(j), is a home occupied as the owner's principal residence, and 11.13(b) exempts $140,000 of its appraised value from school district tax. Once the house is a rental and you live elsewhere, it no longer fits that definition, and the keep side should be priced without the exemption.
The law has one narrow exception, and it is worth reading before you count on it:

For a feel of the size, on purely illustrative numbers: at a school rate of $1.00 per $100 of value, $140,000 of value is $1,400 a year. Use the rate on your own tax statement. Tax Code 23.23(c) adds a second change: the 10% limit on yearly increases in a homestead's appraised value expires on January 1 of the first tax year neither you nor your spouse qualifies for the exemption.
What to do and when to tell the appraisal district is in renting out your home and the homestead exemption.
The rent line: price it from leased Keller comparables
The rent line should come from homes near yours that actually leased, not from asking prices or a city-wide average. Our Keller page says we price from leased Keller comparables for exactly that reason, and our Keller FAQ answers the "what do homes rent for" question the same way: rents vary by neighborhood, size and condition.
Use the lower end of a leased range in your numbers, and leave a month for leasing in year one. The nine factors that move a Keller rent, and how to check each, are in how much could your house rent for in Keller.
If the rent at the low end of the range does not cover the costs in year two, no amount of optimism about the market changes the keep side. That is a selling signal, or a reason to look at the other doors on our rent or sell page.
Who rents in Keller, and what they expect from the house
Our Keller page describes the market we manage: families who plan to stay, drawn by Keller ISD schools, established neighborhoods with larger lots, and a location that reaches both Fort Worth and the Alliance corridor. It also says the bar is high. Keller tenants compare a rental against well-kept owner-occupied homes on the same street, and rentals that look tired sit on the market at any price.
For a sell-or-keep decision that means two things. Budget a real make-ready before the first tenant, and keep a reserve for repairs, because presentation and responsive maintenance are what the rent level is built on.
Check the HOA too. Many Keller neighborhoods have active HOAs, and Property Code 209.016(d) allows an association's documents to restrict occupancy or leasing. Read your restrictions before you plan on a tenant. More Keller-specific checks are in renting out a house in Keller.
Your mortgage rate and the IRS home sale window
Our rent or sell page puts the rate question in one line: a low rate is an asset. If your fixed rate is well below what a new loan would cost, the principal and interest line on the keep side stays lower than the same house would carry at today's rates, and a sale gives that up. A high or adjustable rate weakens the keep side every year. Before you rent, read your note and deed of trust and ask your servicer whether the loan allows the house to be rented.
The IRS side sets a deadline. Publication 523 requires ownership and residence of at least 24 months each within the 5 years before the sale, and the 24 months of residence do not have to be continuous. Five years is 60 months, so if you lived in the house for at least the last 24 months before moving out, a sale up to 36 months after the move can still meet the residence test. Your own dates may differ; ask your CPA for the last qualifying sale date.
Two more points from the same publication: the part of the 5-year period after the last date you used the house as your main home is not "nonqualified use," and gain equal to depreciation allowed or allowable after May 6, 1997 cannot be excluded. IRS Topic 409 taxes unrecaptured section 1250 gain at a maximum 25% rate. Texas, under Constitution article VIII, section 24-b, does not tax an individual's capital gains. This is general information, not tax advice.
An illustrative Keller example, re-added
Here is the arithmetic on a purely illustrative Keller house (every number is illustrative only, not a quote and not a real property).
Sell now: a $500,000 sale price, $30,000 of selling costs and a $280,000 payoff leave $190,000 in cash before any tax.
Keep, year one: rent of $3,000 a month for 11 months is $33,000. Costs: principal and interest $15,600 ($1,300 a month), property tax without the homestead exemption $9,000, landlord insurance $3,000, HOA $700, a management fee of 10% of the rent for the 11 leased months $3,300, a leasing fee of half a month's rent $1,500, repairs $2,000. Total $35,100, so year one runs minus $2,100.
Keep, year two: 12 months of rent is $36,000; the management fee is $3,600 and a $150 renewal fee replaces the leasing fee. Costs total $34,050, so year two runs plus $1,950. Two years together: minus $150, while the $190,000 of equity stays in the house and the tenant's rent pays down the loan.
Whether any fee applies to a vacant month is set in the management agreement; our actual lines are on the pricing page. The yearly sell-or-hold review is in when to sell a rental property.
How the Keller answers usually point
Once your own numbers are in, the Keller answers usually point one way:
- Keep when year two is positive at the low end of the leased range, your rate is low, the HOA allows leasing, and you can fund a make-ready to the street's standard and a reserve.
- Sell when you need the $190,000 (or your own figure) for the next home, year two is still negative with no fix, or your IRS window closes before you would want to sell.
- Look at the other doors when the house is listed and not moving: our rent or sell page also describes listing it yourself through DirectList, a creative exit such as owner finance or subject-to, a full-service listing, and short sale help when the numbers are upside down.
Our Keller page notes that many Keller landlords are owners who moved for work and kept the house; the accidental landlord guide is written for that owner.

How Perpetual helps with a Keller sell-or-keep decision
We are broker-owned, with our office in North Richland Hills about ten minutes from Keller, so both sides of the answer come from one team:
- The keep side: a free rental analysis with a rent range from leased Keller comparables, demand notes, make-ready guidance and a written management quote, typically within one business day. The final fee is set after the analysis and confirmed in writing before you sign.
- The sell side: Perpetual Realty Group can list the house occupied or vacant, and our selling investment property page promises the math for both rather than a one-size answer.
- The whole decision: a discovery call with Justin Brown, Broker/Owner, covering your payoff, rate and equity, what the house would rent for and sell for today, and which door fits. No fee and no obligation; bring your mortgage statement. Call 817-228-6817.
If you keep it and move away, our Keller FAQ says remote owners get portal reporting, photo inspections and disbursements wherever they live; see Keller property management. To start with the rent line, call 682-593-7033.
The takeaway: Price the keep side with the tax bill you will have without the homestead exemption and a rent from leased Keller comparables, put your IRS sale deadline on the calendar, and decide with both numbers in front of you.
Questions owners ask
How much do property taxes go up when I rent out my Keller house?
Most of the change comes from losing the homestead exemption. Tax Code 11.13(b) exempts $140,000 of a homestead's appraised value from school district tax, and Tax Code 23.23(c) ends the 10% appraisal limit on January 1 of the first year you no longer qualify. Multiply the lost exemption by your school district's rate from your tax statement, and ask the appraisal district about your dates.
Can I rent my Keller house for a few years and still avoid capital gains tax when I sell?
Possibly. IRS Publication 523 requires owning and living in the home for at least 24 months of the 5 years before the sale, so if you lived there for at least the 24 months before moving out, a sale up to 36 months later can still meet the test. Gain equal to depreciation after May 6, 1997 cannot be excluded. Ask your CPA for your exact last date.
Is a Keller house a good rental investment?
It can be, when the numbers work on your own house: year two positive at the low end of a leased rent range, a low mortgage rate, an HOA that allows leasing and a long hold. Our Keller page describes tenants who sign longer leases and renew when the home is kept up. Run the illustrative example in this guide with your own figures before deciding.
What happens to my mortgage if I convert my Keller home to a rental?
Your note and deed of trust decide it. Read them and ask your servicer, in writing, whether and when the loan allows the house to be rented, and switch to a landlord policy before the tenant moves in. Our rent or sell page treats a low rate as an asset, which is often the strongest reason to keep rather than sell.
Can I keep the homestead exemption on my Keller house if I rent it out?
Usually not. Tax Code 11.13(j) ties the exemption to a home occupied as the owner's principal residence. The exception in 11.13(l) covers a temporary absence of less than two years when you intend to return and have not established a different principal residence, or an absence caused by military service or a care facility. Ask the Tarrant Appraisal District how it applies to you.
Does Texas tax the gain if I sell my Keller house later?
No state tax: Texas Constitution article VIII, section 24-b, added November 4, 2025, says the legislature may not impose a tax on the realized or unrealized capital gains of an individual. Federal tax can apply, including on gain from depreciation taken while the house was rented. Ask your CPA before you sign a long lease. This is general information, not tax advice.
Property management in Keller, North Richland Hills and Fort Worth. How full-service management works in Tarrant County →


