Call Now Free Rental Analysis
Pricing & Fees

Comparing Property Management Quotes: A Worksheet for Your First-Year Cost

Short answer

Turn every quote into one dollar figure for the first year on your own rent. Put each quote on the same eight lines (monthly fee, leasing, renewal, setup, inspection, maintenance coordination, eviction and cancellation), use the same assumptions for all of them, and add a year-two column. For a rental in Fort Worth, Keller or North Richland Hills, that comparison takes about half an hour and a written quote from each manager.

This guide answers
  • How do I compare two property management quotes fairly?
  • What lines go on a property management fee comparison worksheet?
  • Should I compare property management quotes on the percentage or the dollar amount?
  • How do I account for a leasing fee that is only charged when a tenant changes?
Comparing Property Management Quotes: A Worksheet for Your First-Year Cost

Key takeaways

  • Compare dollars for a year, not headline percentages: every quote goes on the same eight lines.
  • Write your assumptions once (rent, repair spend, a vacant or occupied start) and use them for every quote.
  • Add a year-two column: a big leasing fee wins or loses the comparison depending on the year you look at.
  • Eviction and cancellation charges are risk lines: list them, do not add them to the total.
  • In the illustrative example, the 8% quote costs more in year one than the 10% quote.

To compare property management quotes, turn each one into a single first-year cost on your own rent. Eight lines cover nearly every fee schedule: monthly fee, leasing, renewal, setup, inspection, maintenance coordination, eviction and cancellation. For a rental in Fort Worth, Keller or North Richland Hills, fill them in from each written quote, add them up, then check year two before you choose.

Below is the blank worksheet, how to convert each line into dollars, an illustrative three-quote example added up twice, and the questions that make the numbers trustworthy.

The worksheet: eight lines, one column per quote

Copy this grid onto paper or a spreadsheet. Each line has a rule for turning the quote into year-one dollars:

LineTurn it into year-one dollarsQuote 1Quote 2Quote 3
1. Monthly management feePercentage x your monthly rent x 12, or the flat fee x 12____________
2. Leasing (tenant placement) feeCount it once if a tenant is placed this year; 0 if a tenant is already in place____________
3. Lease renewal fee0 in year one if the first lease runs 12 months; enter it in the year-two column____________
4. Setup, onboarding or enrollment feeCount it once, in year one____________
5. Inspection feesFee per inspection x the inspections you will be billed for____________
6. Maintenance coordination or markupThe stated percentage x your yearly repair spend____________
7. Eviction coverage or feeA monthly plan x 12 goes in the total; a per-case fee goes on the risk list____________
8. Cancellation feeRisk list only; write the amount and the notice period____________
Other monthly chargesTechnology, admin or statement fees x 12____________
Year-one totalLines 1 to 7 plus other monthly charges____________

How to read this table: every quote gets every line, even when the answer is zero, and a zero only counts once it is in writing. Lines 7 and 8 behave differently because some charges depend on events that may never happen; how to handle them is below.

Write your assumptions once, at the top

A worksheet only compares quotes if every column uses the same assumptions. Write four of them above the grid:

  • Monthly rent. Use a figure from leased comparables, not a hope. A free rental analysis gives you one.
  • How the year starts. Vacant (a tenant will be placed, so line 2 counts) or a tenant already in place (line 2 is zero this year).
  • Repair spend. Your yearly total of vendor invoices. Use your own records or a rough estimate; line 6 is a percentage of it.
  • Inspections you will be billed for. Read each quote for what is included and what is extra.

Then add what each quote does not say. A blank is not a zero. Write "ask" in the cell and send the question by email, so the answer arrives in writing.

Keep the headline rates out of the comparison until the end. A percentage on its own says nothing about the leasing fee, the renewal fee or the markup, which is why the hidden property management fees checklist exists.

A worked example: three quotes, one rent

Here are three illustrative quotes, invented for this example (none is our plan), on a house that rents for $1,950 a month. Assume the first tenant is placed at the start, 12 months of rent are collected in year one, vendor invoices total $1,800 for the year, one inspection is billed, and the lease renews at the end of year one:

LineQuote A: 8%Quote B: 10%Quote C: $129 flat
1. Monthly fee x 12$156 x 12 = $1,872$195 x 12 = $2,340$129 x 12 = $1,548
2. Leasing fee100% of one month = $1,95060% of one month = $1,170$995 flat
3. Renewal (year two)($250)($175)($195)
4. Setup$300$0$250
5. Inspection$95Included: $0$75
6. Repairs: markup or coordination10% of $1,800 = $1806% of $1,800 = $108At cost: $0
7. Eviction$500 per case (risk list)$10 a month = $120$350 per case (risk list)
Other monthly charges$0$0Technology fee $8 x 12 = $96
Year-one total$4,397$3,738$2,964
Share of $23,400 year-one rent18.8%16.0%12.7%

How to read this table: the renewal fee in brackets is not in the year-one total, and the per-case eviction fees go on the risk list. The quote with the lowest percentage, A, is the most expensive in year one, because its leasing fee alone is a full month of rent. Illustrative only, not a quote.

Added up line by line: A is $1,872 + $1,950 + $300 + $95 + $180 = $4,397. B is $2,340 + $1,170 + $108 + $120 = $3,738. C is $1,548 + $995 + $250 + $75 + $96 = $2,964. Added the other way, from the smallest line up, A is $180 + $95 + $300 + $1,950 + $1,872 = $4,397, B is $120 + $108 + $1,170 + $2,340 = $3,738, and C is $96 + $75 + $250 + $995 + $1,548 = $2,964.

Each percentage line is worked on the rent you wrote at the top. If the rent rises, lines 1, 2 and 6 rise with it on a percentage quote but not on a flat one; the flat fee vs. percentage guide shows how that plays out.

Check year two before you decide

The first year carries the one-time charges: the leasing fee and any setup or enrollment fee. Year two carries the renewal fee instead. A quote that looks expensive in year one can be the cheaper one from then on, and the reverse.

In the example above, the year-two totals are $2,397 for A, $2,743 for B and $1,914 for C. A, the most expensive quote in year one, is cheaper than B in year two because its large leasing fee is gone and its monthly fee is lower. Over two years the totals are $4,397 + $2,397 = $6,794 for A, $3,738 + $2,743 = $6,481 for B and $2,964 + $1,914 = $4,878 for C.

The other year-two case is a new tenant instead of a renewal. Then the leasing fee comes back: A's year two becomes $1,872 + $1,950 + $95 + $180 = $4,097, B's $2,340 + $1,170 + $108 + $120 = $3,738 and C's $1,548 + $995 + $75 + $96 = $2,714. If you expect turnover, the leasing line matters more than the monthly rate. All illustrative.

Make every number true before you add it up

Each cell is only as good as the answer behind it. Ask one question per line, by email, and date each answer:

A manager who answers all seven in writing has given you a usable column. A manager who will not is telling you how the statements will read.

Risk lines: list them next to the total, do not add them

Some charges cannot be added up honestly, because they depend on events that may never happen. Keep them in a short list under the totals instead of inside them:

  • Per-case eviction fees. $500 for A and $350 for C in the example. If an eviction happens, it is a large cost; if it does not, it is zero. B's $10 a month buys coverage and is already in B's total.
  • Cancellation terms. The fee, the notice period and what you owe on a tenant the manager placed. These decide how expensive it is to leave a manager who disappoints you.
  • Empty months. Lost rent is income you did not receive, not a management fee, so it stays off this worksheet. What it costs is in what a vacant month really costs.

Read the risk list next to the totals. A quote that is $300 cheaper a year but charges a cancellation fee of several months' fees may not be cheaper for you.

How Perpetual fills in its own lines

Perpetual Property Management is broker-owned, with our office in North Richland Hills, and we manage rentals in Keller, North Richland Hills, Fort Worth and nearby. Our price sheet publishes three plans, and every line of the worksheet can be filled from it:

  • Line 1: 7% of monthly rent (Investor Special, portfolios of 5 or more units), 9% (Standard) or 10% (Full Service).
  • Line 2: tenant placement at 50% of one month's rent (Investor Special and Full Service) or 75% (Standard).
  • Line 3: lease renewal at $149, $200 or $150, in the same plan order.
  • Line 4: the price sheet has no line called a setup fee; the start-up line is the property enrollment inspection at $125, $49 or included.
  • Line 5: an annual property inspection is listed on every plan.
  • Line 6: make-ready coordination 3% to 5% of cost (Investor Special), maintenance coordination 4.9% of cost (Standard) or 5% of cost (Full Service). It is a percentage of the vendor's invoice, and the original invoice is always in your portal.
  • Line 7: optional eviction service at $7.95 per month (Investor Special and Standard); included on Full Service.
  • Line 8: not on the price sheet, so it is confirmed in writing in the management agreement before you sign.
Screenshot of the closing section of the Perpetual Property Management pricing page, headed Get your exact management quote in writing, with the sentence about a personalized quote with every fee spelled out outlined
The end of our price sheet: a free rental analysis comes with a personalized quote that spells out every fee, which is what the three columns of your worksheet need. Screenshot: perpetualpm.com, November 2026.

The final fee is set after the rental analysis, plans are negotiable case by case, and every number is confirmed in writing before you sign. If a fee is not in the agreement, you do not pay it. To fill in a column for your own house, request a free rental analysis or call 682-593-7033.

The glass double-door entrance of a gray brick office building with river-rock landscaping, the Perpetual Property Management office in North Richland Hills, Texas
The entrance to our office in North Richland Hills, where written quotes for rentals in Keller, North Richland Hills and Fort Worth are prepared.

The takeaway: Fill in the same eight lines for every quote, compare the first-year dollars and the year-two dollars, list eviction and cancellation as risks, and then choose among the finalists on service, not on the sheet alone.

Questions owners ask

How do I compare two property management quotes fairly?

Turn each quote into dollars for one year on your own rent. Put every fee on the same eight lines (monthly fee, leasing, renewal, setup, inspection, maintenance coordination, eviction and cancellation), use the same assumptions for every quote, and write a zero only when it is confirmed in writing. Add the year-one total, then a year-two column, and list per-case eviction fees and cancellation terms as risks next to the totals.

Should I compare quotes on the percentage or the dollar amount?

On dollars. A percentage hides the leasing fee, the renewal fee and any markup. In the illustrative example on this page, an 8% quote costs $4,397 in year one and a 10% quote costs $3,738, because the 8% quote charges a full month's rent to place a tenant. Only the dollar totals show that.

How do I account for a leasing fee that is only charged when a tenant changes?

Count it in the year a tenant is placed. If the house is vacant now, it is in your year-one column; if a tenant is already in place, it is zero this year. Then add a year-two column and decide whether you expect a renewal (the renewal fee) or a new tenant (the leasing fee again).

Is the cheapest property management quote usually a good deal?

Not always. In the illustrative example, the 8% quote produced the highest first-year cost because of its leasing fee, while a flat-fee quote came in lowest but added a monthly technology fee and a per-case eviction fee. The worksheet shows the dollars; the decision still depends on what each manager does for them.

What if a manager will not give me a complete fee list?

Treat that as an answer. Fill in the lines you can, write "ask" in the rest, and send the missing questions by email. A manager who cannot list every fee before you sign is unlikely to be clearer on your monthly statements.

What lines go on a property management fee comparison worksheet?

Eight: the monthly management fee, the leasing or tenant placement fee, the lease renewal fee, any setup or enrollment fee, inspection fees, maintenance coordination or markup, eviction coverage or fees, and the cancellation fee. Add a line for any other monthly charge, such as a technology fee. The first seven, plus other monthly charges, make the year-one total; cancellation is a risk line.

Should the cancellation fee be part of the first-year cost?

No. You only pay it if you leave, so adding it would distort the comparison. Write the fee and the notice period on the risk list under the totals and weigh it there. A low annual cost with an expensive exit can be the worse deal if the service disappoints.

Property management in Keller, North Richland Hills and Fort Worth. How full-service management works in Tarrant County →

Keep reading

Related owner guides

Pricing & Fees

Is Full-Service Property Management Worth the Higher Fee? A Worked Example

The plan with the higher monthly percentage is not always the more expensive one. Here is how to compare plan levels at one company year by year, with a worked example built from our own published fees.

Pricing & Fees

Hidden Property Management Fees to Ask About Before You Sign

The fee on the front of the brochure is rarely the whole price. Here is every add-on a management agreement can carry, what each one should cost you, and how to get the full list in writing.

Pricing & Fees

Flat Fee vs. Percentage Property Management: Which Is Better for Owners?

A percentage fee ties the manager's pay to your rent. A flat fee is predictable and favors higher-rent houses. Neither is better in every case, and the structure matters less than what it includes.

Ready to see what your rental should earn?

Request a free rental analysis and get a clear picture of market rent, demand, and what professional management would look like for your property. No obligation.