Call Now Free Rental Analysis
Choosing a Manager

Should I Ask to Speak With Other Owners They Work With? A Reference-Call Script

Short answer

Yes. Ask to speak with another owner the company works with, ideally one with a house like yours who has been through a tenant turnover. Ask about events, not satisfaction: the last turnover, a large repair, a late payment, a surprise charge. Allow a few days for the company to get the owner's permission, and treat a flat refusal with no alternative as a warning. It works the same for a manager in Fort Worth, Keller or North Richland Hills.

This guide answers
  • Should I ask to speak with other owners they work with?
  • What questions should I ask a property manager's owner reference?
  • How do I know a property manager's reference is a real owner?
  • What if a property manager won't give references?
Should I Ask to Speak With Other Owners They Work With? A Reference-Call Script

Key takeaways

  • Yes, ask: a reference call is the nearest thing to a year with the company before you sign.
  • Ask for an owner whose house and situation resemble yours and who has been through a turnover.
  • Ask about events, not feelings: turnover, repairs, late rent, statements, renewals.
  • A few days' delay for permission is normal; a refusal with no alternative is a finding.
  • You can test that a reference is a real owner without asking for any private data.

Should you ask to speak with other owners a property manager works with? Yes. Ask for one owner whose house resembles yours and who has been a client long enough to see a tenant move out and a new one move in. A ten-minute call with that owner, about specific events, tells you more than any sales meeting. It works the same whether you are comparing managers in Fort Worth, Keller or North Richland Hills.

This guide is the call itself: how to ask, a ten-question script with what good and weak answers sound like, how to read a delay or a refusal, and how to make sure the person on the phone is a real owner.

The ten-question reference-call script

Use these ten questions in this order. Each asks about something that happened, which is hard to answer with a general compliment. The middle and right columns show what to listen for:

Ask the referenceA good answer sounds likeA weak answer sounds like
1. How long have you been with them, and for which homes?A number of years and the houses, by city or type"A while," with no detail
2. At your last turnover, how long from move-out to the new move-in, and what did it cost?Dates or weeks, the main repairs and roughly what they cost"Not long," or no turnover yet
3. Tell me about a repair above your approval limit. What did you get before saying yes?A description, photos, a recommendation and a price"They just handle it," or learning of it on the statement
4. Has a tenant ever paid late? When did you hear, and what happened next?Told early, with the steps that followedFound out at month-end, or never told
5. Can you read your monthly statement without calling them?Names the lines: rent, fees, repairs, the payout"My accountant deals with it"
6. Has a charge ever surprised you? How was it settled?One specific charge and how it was explained or reversed"I never really look"
7. Who is your day-to-day contact, and has that changed?A name or role, and how a change was handledA different person every time
8. How fast are calls and emails answered?A usual time and one example"Eventually," or "it depends who you get"
9. What happened at your last renewal?When the offer came, the rent advice, and that the owner decidedThe lease renewed and the owner was not asked
10. What is one thing you wish they did better?One honest, specific criticism"Nothing at all"

How to read this table: one weak answer is normal; every owner has a blind spot. Two or three weak answers on the same subject, such as repairs or statements, is a pattern worth raising with the company. Question 10 is the most useful: an owner who can name one thing to improve is being candid about the other nine.

Write the answers down during the call. If you speak with references for two companies, the same ten questions make the notes comparable. The numbers behind questions 2, 4 and 9 can then be checked against what the company itself reports, as described in how to check references for a property management company: the numbers.

How to ask so you get a useful reference

The wording matters. "Can I talk to some of your clients?" gets you the company's happiest owner, whose house may look nothing like yours. Ask instead: "Could you connect me with an owner who has a single-family house in Keller or North Richland Hills, has been with you a couple of years, and has been through a tenant turnover?" Swap in your own city and situation: one house or several, a tenant in place, an owner who lives out of state.

That request gets you someone whose experience predicts yours, and it shows the company you know where management is tested. Send it by email, so the request and the answer are on record, and expect the company to ask the owner's permission first, which can take a few days.

One well-matched reference is usually enough. Ask for a second if the company manages different kinds of property and the first owner's house is unlike yours.

Running the call: order, notes and follow-ups

Most owners agree to ten or fifteen minutes. Use them in three parts:

  1. Context first (one minute). Say who you are, what you own and that you are deciding between managers. Owners answer more openly when they know why you are asking.
  2. The ten questions (ten minutes). Go in order. When an answer is general, ask "what happened next?" or "roughly when was that?" Those two follow-ups turn an impression into an event.
  3. The close (two minutes). Ask whether there is anything you should have asked and did not. Thank them, and do not call again unless they offered.

Take notes in the owner's words, not your summary of them. "Took about three weeks after the tenant left" is evidence; "seemed fine" is not. For the bigger structure of comparing companies, put the call's notes into a weighted interview scorecard so the reference counts as one input, not the whole decision.

How to read a delay, a condition or a refusal

A delay of a few days while the company asks permission is normal and is a decent sign: it means owners' contact details are not handed out freely. A delay that stretches into weeks with excuses is not.

A condition, such as "we can connect you once you have the agreement in hand," is reasonable if it comes with a date. A condition that always moves is a polite refusal.

A flat refusal deserves one direct follow-up: "I understand. What else can I see that shows how you work?" A good company will point to something checkable, such as its fee schedule, a sample of what owners receive, its license record or its reviews. A company that refuses references and offers nothing else is asking to be judged on the sales pitch alone.

A reference who turns out to be a relative, a business partner or a client of two months is a reference in name only. Count it as no reference.

Why some good companies limit references

Some well-run companies are slow to give references, and not because they hide something. Owners who get called often stop agreeing to it, so a company may rotate a small group of willing owners. The reference is real, but it is chosen.

So treat a reference as one source among several. Pair it with reviews, where the company does not choose who speaks, and with the documents you can ask to see. How to weigh reviews is in how to read property management reviews, and how to test a review's claims is in landlord reviews vs tenant reviews. If the reference, the reviews and the documents describe the same company, trust the picture. If the reference glows and the reviews describe something else, believe the pattern in the reviews.

How to check the reference is a real owner, without asking for private data

You do not need the owner's address, statements or account details to know you are talking to a real client. You need answers that only a real client could give. Four checks do it:

  • The introduction. Ask the company to introduce you by email, copying the owner, rather than giving you a phone number. You then see the owner's own email reply, and the owner has clearly agreed to talk.
  • The relationship question. Ask early: "Do you work for the company, or have any business with it besides management, such as being a vendor, a relative or a partner?" A reference with another tie is not neutral.
  • Detail only a client knows. Ask what the statement shows each month, roughly when the payout arrives, and how a repair approval reaches them. A real owner answers from habit; a stand-in answers in slogans.
  • The general area, not the address. Ask which city or part of town the house is in and how old it is. That is enough to know whether the experience predicts yours.

Do not ask for copies of statements, the tenant's name or the house number. A good company will not hand those out, and a good reference should not either. If the answers to the four checks hang together, the reference is real.

An illustrative reference call

Here is how a good call might sound. This is an illustrative call, not a real one. You reach an owner with a house in Fort Worth who has been with the company for three years. On question 2, they say the tenant gave notice in spring, the company sent a photo report and a repair list with prices within a week of move-out, the work took about two weeks, and the house was listed with new photos once it was clean. They add that the deposit itemization went out on time and the tenant did not dispute it.

On question 10, they say the renewal conversation started later than they wanted one year. That is the shape to look for: specific events, rough dates, a paper trail and one honest criticism. A reference who cannot describe a single event is not much of a reference.

Asking Perpetual for a reference

Perpetual Property Management is broker-owned, with our office in North Richland Hills, and we manage rentals in Keller, North Richland Hills, Fort Worth and the surrounding Northeast Tarrant County communities. Our website does not publish an owner reference list, so ask us for a reference call and judge the answer by the standards in this guide. While you wait, these can be checked today:

  • Our reviews. Our reviews page shows excerpts from our public Zillow profile, reproduced with the original reviewer usernames, and links to all of them. Most of the excerpts describe buying or selling with Justin Brown, so they speak to the brokerage side; a reference call about management covers what they do not.
  • Our licenses. Perpetual Property Management is a registered assumed name of Perpetual Realty Group, LLC, TREC Broker Company License 9008702-BB. Justin Brown, Broker/Owner, holds TREC Broker License 549418-B, licensed since 2006. Both can be looked up on the TREC License Holder Search.
  • Our fees and promises. Every fee is on our price sheet, confirmed in writing before you sign; if a fee is not in the agreement, you do not pay it. The five guarantees in the Perpetual Promise each come with a stated remedy, subject to the Guarantee Addendum.
Screenshot of the bottom of the Perpetual Property Management reviews page: a See All Reviews on Zillow button and the note Reviews shown are excerpts from our public Zillow profile, reproduced with original reviewer usernames, outlined
The note under our review quotes says where they come from and the button opens the full profile. A reference call adds what a page of excerpts cannot: one owner's account of management, in detail. Screenshot: perpetualpm.com, November 2026.
A single-story rental house with white and gray siding, a cedar slat accent wall and a covered front porch with stone steps, managed by Perpetual Property Management in Hurst, Texas
A Perpetual-managed rental in Hurst. Ask for a reference whose house is like yours in age, type and city; that owner's experience predicts yours best.

Bring the ten questions to us as well as to our references. To start with your own house, request a free rental analysis or call 682-593-7033.

The takeaway: Ask for an owner reference that matches your situation, run the ten questions about events, read the company's response to the request as part of the answer, and check the reference is a real owner before you trust what you hear.

Questions owners ask

How many owner references should I ask a property manager for?

One well-matched reference is usually enough if you ask about specific events. Ask for two if the company manages different kinds of property, so you hear from an owner whose house resembles yours. Asking for five or more is unlikely to be met, because most owners do not want repeated calls, and extra calls rarely change the decision.

What if the owner reference says something negative?

Take it seriously, in proportion. One criticism from an otherwise satisfied owner, such as a slow renewal conversation, is normal and honest. A criticism that matches a pattern in the reviews, such as slow repairs or surprise charges, is a real finding. Ask the company about it directly and judge the answer on whether it is specific and whether anything changed.

Can I ask to speak with a tenant the company manages instead?

You can ask, but many companies will decline for privacy reasons, and a tenant cannot tell you about statements, fees or owner communication. The closest substitute is reading tenant reviews for repairs and communication. That gives you the tenant's view without putting anyone on the spot.

Should I ask the reference how much they pay in fees?

You can, but the answer may not match your quote, since fees can vary by property, portfolio size and when the owner signed. The more useful question is whether the fees on their statements have matched the written quote they were given, and whether anything has appeared that they did not expect. That tells you about the company's honesty, which carries over to your agreement regardless of the numbers.

How do I know a property manager's reference is a real owner?

Ask for an email introduction that copies the owner, ask whether they have any tie to the company besides management, and ask detail only a client knows: what the monthly statement shows, roughly when the payout arrives, how repair approvals reach them. Ask the city and age of the house, not the address. If the answers hang together, the reference is real.

What if a property manager won't give references?

Ask once: "What else can I see that shows how you work?" A good company points to something checkable, such as its fee schedule, a sample of what owners receive, its license record or its reviews. A company that refuses references and offers nothing else is asking to be judged on its sales pitch alone; weigh that heavily.

Property management in Keller, North Richland Hills and Fort Worth. How full-service management works in Tarrant County →

Keep reading

Related owner guides

Choosing a Manager

Checking a Property Manager's Track Record: Numbers and Owner References

A manager's track record is four things: public records, performance numbers, owner references and a test you run yourself. Here is what to request, how to read it and what to ask the other owners.

Choosing a Manager

How to Read Property Management Reviews: Owner vs. Tenant Complaints

A property manager's reviews are written by two groups with opposite interests. Some tenant complaints are proof the company is doing its job for you. Others are a warning. Here is how to tell them apart in ten minutes.

Choosing a Manager

What to See at the First Consultation: Sample Agreement, Statement and Plan

Before you pay a property manager anything, you should have seen a sample agreement, a sample owner statement and a written plan for your house. Here is what each should contain and how to read it.

Ready to see what your rental should earn?

Request a free rental analysis and get a clear picture of market rent, demand, and what professional management would look like for your property. No obligation.